Revenue & metrics

AdSense vs Google Ad Manager: when a publisher outgrows AdSense, and what changes if you switch

Last updated Published By the editorial team6 min6 sources

Key takeaways

  • AdSense is an ad network that fills your ad space automatically from an auction; Google Ad Manager is a platform to manage all your ad sales, including direct campaigns and multiple demand sources.
  • Google's Ad Manager sign-up pages state that you need an AdSense account to work with Google Ad Manager.
  • Ad Manager uses the Google Publisher Tag (GPT), and live ads from your own network need an active line item in Ready status and an ad tag for the ad unit.
  • Both AdSense and Ad Manager run first-price auctions: Google aligned AdSense with Ad Manager and AdMob when it moved AdSense to first-price, announced October 7, 2021.
  • The published AdSense revenue share figures cover AdSense; they do not describe Ad Manager pricing.
Roadside billboards and advertising signs crowded along a street
Image: BILLBOARDS AND ADVERTISING CLUTTER ROADSIDE - NARA - 546184,Marc St. Gil,Public domain,via Wikimedia Commons.

AdSense is an ad network: you add one piece of code, Google’s auction fills your ad space, and you receive a revenue share. Google Ad Manager is an ad management platform: you define inventory, sell campaigns directly, bring in several demand sources and control how they compete. Ad Manager is worth the extra work when you have direct advertisers or multiple demand partners to manage, not merely because traffic grew.

What does each product do?

AdSense Google Ad Manager
What it is An ad network with automatic placement and auction A platform to “take control of all your ad sales”
Who sells your ads Google’s auction, automatically You (direct deals) plus programmatic demand
Main setup AdSense code, Auto ads or ad units Ad units, line items, Google Publisher Tag
Direct campaigns No Yes: direct-booked campaigns, Programmatic Guaranteed
Multiple demand sources Google demand plus authorized buyers Manage “all your demand sources from one place on one tag”
Formats In-page ad units plus overlay formats such as anchor and vignette Video, native and custom formats, across sites and apps
Auction First-price First-price
Brand safety Blocking controls, Ad review center Publisher controls, Ad review center
Learning curve Low High

The Ad Manager description comes from Google’s Ad Manager home page, its capabilities page and its yield management page, which describe working “from reservations to open auctions” and locking in revenue “with direct-booked campaigns or Programmatic Guaranteed.” The AdSense side is covered across this section, starting with CPC vs CPM bids.

Who can use Google Ad Manager?

Google’s Ad Manager sign-up flow, present on its marketing pages, asks two questions: approximately how many monthly pageviews your website has (less than 1 million, or 1 million or more) and whether you have a Google AdSense account. If you do not, it says: “You need an AdSense account to work with Google Ad Manager. Sign up and come back after your application has been approved.”

So the path is AdSense first. The pageview question signals that Google segments Ad Manager offers by size, but the sign-up page does not state a minimum. The paid enterprise tier and its contract terms are not covered by the public pages reviewed for this guide.

What Google says about smaller publishers

Ad Manager is not only for large media groups. Google’s Ad Manager page for small businesses offers “free, ready-to-use business advertising solutions” and describes the value as being able to “supplement your direct reservations with ads from millions of advertisers across Google’s network.” Read the second phrase carefully: the pitch assumes you have direct reservations to supplement. Without them, Ad Manager mostly gives you a more complex way to reach the same Google demand.

What changes technically if you switch?

The tag

Ad Manager uses the Google Publisher Tag (GPT), which Google describes as “an ad tagging library for Google Ad Manager.” GPT takes the ad unit code, ad size and custom targeting, builds the request and displays the ad.

GPT’s getting-started guide also shows the operational difference. To display a live ad from your own network, “you need to make sure there’s an active line item already trafficked in the ‘Ready’ status,” and you generate an ad tag for the ad unit. In AdSense there is no trafficking step: the auction does it for you.

The workflow

Task AdSense Ad Manager
Add a new slot Create an ad unit or let Auto ads place it Create an ad unit, define sizes, update GPT tags
Sell to a sponsor Not possible inside AdSense Create an order and line items, set priority and delivery
Bring in other buyers Limited to AdSense demand and authorized buyers Configure demand sources and how they compete
Report AdSense reports Ad Manager reporting across all sources
Brand safety Blocking controls and Ad review center Publisher controls; the Ad review center is available in AdSense, Ad Manager and AdMob

The last row comes from Google’s Ad review center overview, which says you can find it “on the Brand safety page in your AdSense, Ad Manager, or AdMob account.”

Measurement details

When AdSense demand fills Ad Manager inventory, some AdSense metrics behave differently. For instance, Google’s Active View glossary entries say those metrics do not include data from dynamic allocation in Google Ad Manager. Plan your reporting before switching, so you do not compare figures that are measured in different places. See Active View viewability.

What about auctions and revenue share?

Both products now run first-price auctions. In Moving AdSense to a first-price auction (October 7, 2021), Google said many platforms, “including Google Ad Manager and Google AdMob,” had already switched to first-price, and that moving AdSense aligned the three.

On fees, be careful: the AdSense revenue share page (80% after the advertiser platform’s fee, about 68% for Google Ads purchases) describes AdSense. It is not a statement about Ad Manager pricing, which depends on the product tier and your agreements. Details on AdSense figures: AdSense revenue share.

When have you outgrown AdSense?

Traffic alone is not the trigger. These are the situations where Ad Manager’s extra tools have something to work with:

Signal Why Ad Manager helps
Advertisers ask to sponsor sections, newsletters or events Direct-booked campaigns need line items and delivery control
You want guaranteed deals with agencies Programmatic Guaranteed
You run, or plan to run, header bidding with several demand partners Ad Manager can manage multiple demand sources together
You need video or native formats beyond what AdSense offers Ad Manager supports video, native and custom formats
Several sites, apps or teams share inventory One platform for all inventory and reporting

And the signals that you probably have not outgrown it:

  • You have no direct advertisers and no plan to sell.
  • Nobody on your team can spend regular time on trafficking and troubleshooting.
  • Your main goal is higher RPM with the same demand. In that case, start with viewability, layout and fewer blocks; see blocking controls.

If header bidding is your reason, understand the trade-offs first: Prebid.js and header bidding.

A decision checklist

  1. List your demand. Write down the direct advertisers, agencies or demand partners you would add. If the list is empty, Ad Manager mostly adds complexity.
  2. Estimate operational time. Line items, creatives, delivery checks and reporting take hours every week.
  3. Check eligibility. Make sure your AdSense account is in good standing; Google’s sign-up flow requires one.
  4. Plan the tag migration. Inventory every AdSense placement and decide its GPT equivalent, including how you will test it.
  5. Plan reporting. Decide which system is the source of truth for revenue and how you will compare before and after.
  6. Keep policies in mind. Ad Manager does not relax content or traffic rules. See invalid traffic explained.

Common mistakes

  • Switching for “higher RPM” with no new demand. The same buyers through a more complex tool rarely change much.
  • Applying AdSense revenue share figures to Ad Manager. They are different products with different terms.
  • Forgetting line items. Live GPT ads from your network need an active line item in “Ready” status.
  • Comparing reports across systems without aligning definitions. Impressions, viewability and earnings can be measured differently.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between AdSense and Google Ad Manager?

AdSense fills your ad slots automatically: you place code, advertisers bid in an auction and the winning ads show. Google Ad Manager is an ad management platform: you define your own ad units, sell campaigns directly to advertisers, bring in several demand sources and decide how they compete, using tools such as line items, reservations and Programmatic Guaranteed deals.

Do I need AdSense to use Google Ad Manager?

Google's Ad Manager sign-up flow says: You need an AdSense account to work with Google Ad Manager, and asks you to sign up for AdSense and come back after your application has been approved. The same flow also asks how many monthly pageviews your site has, with the choices less than 1 million or 1 million or more.

Will Google Ad Manager earn more than AdSense?

Not automatically. Ad Manager gives you tools to add demand (direct deals, other buyers) and manage competition, but those tools only add revenue if you have advertisers to sell to or demand partners to bring in, and the time to operate them. Google does not publish a figure comparing AdSense and Ad Manager earnings for the same site.

Can I use AdSense code and Ad Manager tags on the same site?

The two products use different tags: AdSense uses its own ad code, Ad Manager uses the Google Publisher Tag. The public pages reviewed for this guide do not describe combining them on one site, so check both products' official setup documentation, and plan so that each slot is served by one system and both setups follow their policies.

Sources

  1. Google Ad Manager: Integrated Advertising Management Platform · Google Ad Manager
  2. Business Advertising Management Solutions (small business) · Google Ad Manager
  3. Get started with Google Publisher Tag · Google for Developers
  4. Moving AdSense to a first-price auction · Google (The Keyword blog), October 7, 2021
  5. AdSense revenue share · Google AdSense Help
  6. Ad review center overview · Google AdSense Help